Date
10 June 2019

Tag

Active

Country
Spain Spain
Geographical scope
Local
Type
  • Type

    Employment contract

    Legal
View Court ruling

Description

The Juzgado de lo Social (Employment Court) in Valencia, Spain, on 10 June 2019 ruled in favour of 97 Deliveroo riders,declaring that they were in an employment relationship with the platform. The court case was initiated by the Social Security Treasury (TGSS) against Roodfoods Spain SL (operating as Deliveroo); the dispute centred on whether the riders were independent contractors or employees.

The riders brought several reasons to claim they were employees, including:

  • They were subject to Deliveroo's organization and control, with the company setting their schedules, assigning tasks, and monitoring their performance.
  • They were required to follow specific procedures and guidelines set by Deliveroo, including the use of a specific app and uniform.
  • They were not truly independent, as they relied on Deliveroo's platform to find work and were subject to the company's disciplinary actions.
  • They were integrated into Deliveroo's business, with the company providing them with equipment and training.

Motivation for Ruling in Favour of Employee Status:

  • Integration: Riders were integrated into Deliveroo's organisational framework.
  • Control: Deliveroo's algorithms controlled work distribution and performance monitoring.
  • Dependency: Riders depended on Deliveroo's platform for job execution.
  • Instructions: Detailed instructions provided by Deliveroo dictated work conduct.
  • Penalties: Riders faced penalties for non-compliance, indicating control.
  • Uniformity: Use of Deliveroo-branded equipment and uniforms.

Additional metadata

Keywords
autonomy and control, employment status
Actors
Court
Sector
Transportation and storage
Platforms
Deliveroo

Citation

Eurofound (2019), Valencia Court Rules Deliveroo Riders as Employees - GCJ case - SJSO 2892/2019 (Court ruling), Record number 3103, Platform Economy Database, Dublin, https://apps.eurofound.europa.eu/platformeconomydb/valencia-court-rules-deliveroo-riders-as-employees-gcj-case-sjso-28922019-102542.