Description
On November 11th 2024, the new EU directive 2024/2831 on improving working conditions in platform work was published in the Official Journal of the EU. It ented into force on 1 December 2024 and must be implemented into national law by 2 December 2026 at the latest.
The key objectives of the directive are:
1) Clarification of platform workers' employment status;
2) Putting in place strict rules concerning algorithmic management and human oversight;
3) Transparency and data protection.
The original proposal sought to address issues of misclassification of employment contract through a set of criteria aiming to establish control. According to the proposal, a legal presumption of employment existed if at least two out of a list of five criteria laid out in Chapter 2, Article 4 were met:
- the salary or limit thereof is determined by the platform;
- there are electronic means to monitor and assess a workers’ performance;
- there are legally obligatory guidelines governing how one should present oneself, interact with clients, and carry out the work;
- there are limitations on working time, restrictions on one's freedom to turn off the App, or to use a substitute; and
- exclusivity or non-competition is necessary, i.e. a person is limited in that they cannot work for a third party.
However, these indicators for a presumption of employment were revised during negotiations. The agreed text of the Directive indicates that each Member State is responsible for establishing a legal presumption of employment in their legal systems, to be triggered when facts indicating control and direction are found. The facts indicating control will be determined according to national law and collective agreements, while taking into account EU case-law. The Directive also specifies that the presumption of employment does not have retroactive effects and, thus, only applies once it has been transposed into national legislation by the Member States.
Importantly, Article 5 of the Directive also provides platforms with the possibility to rebut the presumption by proving that the relationship at stake cannot be classified as an employment relationship based on the respective Member State’s legislation.
The Directive also addresses the issue of algorithmic management. In Articles 6-8 of Chapter 3 of the Directive, it is explained that decisions made or assisted by automated means which substantially impact the working conditions of platform workers must be overseen and managed by human beings who possess the requisite knowledge, skills, and authority to do so. Platform workers are also able to request an explanation of such decisions and can appeal them. Moreover, the Directive prohibits the processing of certain forms of data, namely data on private conversations, data on predicted or actual trade union membership, on the emotional state of platform workers, on a worker’s ethnic background, migration status, political or religious opinions, health status, or biometric data. Generally, workers must be informed about the use of automated monitoring as well as automated decision-making systems.
Notably, Chapter 4 of the Directive establishes that digital labour platforms that function as employers are required to report work carried out by platform workers to the relevant labour and social protection authorities of the Member State in which the work is completed and to share pertinent data with those authorities. This is especially relevant for platforms that are based in another country than the one where platform work is carried out.
Lastly, Chapter 5 indicates that Member States must provide access to dispute resolution mechanisms regarding issues included in the Directive and establishes that rights set up through the Directive cannot be infringed upon. More specifically, Article 18 deals with the protection of dismissal for platform workers. It states that if an individual is dismissed, or if their account is deactivating as a result of exercising rights established by the Directive, the platform is obliged to prove that there were other objective reasons underlying the dismissal of a worker.
Background
* 9 December 2021: The Commission published proposal on improving working conditions in platform work.
* 12 June 2023: Employment and social affairs ministers agreed on the Council’s general approach.
* 11 July 2023 - 8 February 2024: Negotiations with the European Parliament began and were concluded with an agreement reached on 8 February 2024.
* March 2024: The agreement was confirmed the EU Ministers for Employment and Social Affairs;
* On April 24th 2024 a political agreement had been reached between the European Parliament and Member States .
Updates (4)
The following recent changes to this initiative have been recorded.
- 22 November 2024
9/12/2021 - Proposal for a DIRECTIVE OF THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT AND OF THE COUNCIL on improving working conditions in platform work (COM/2021/762 final)
https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELEX:52021PC0762
- 22 November 2024
13/12/2023 - Provisional agreement on the platform work directive reached between negotiators from Parliament and Council
- 22 November 2024
24/04/2024 - Parliament adopts Platform Work Directive - New rules to correct false self-employment
Workers cannot be fired based on a decision taken by an algorithm
Platforms forbidden from processing certain types of personal data
- 22 November 2024
- Keywords
-
algorithm,
algorithmic management,
employment status,
regulatory changes
- Actors
-
Government
Sources