Date
14 November 2022

Tag

Active

Country
Spain Spain
Geographical scope
Regional
Type
  • Type

    Other (legal)

    Legal
  • Type

    Employment contract

    Legal
View Court ruling

Description

The judgment of the Employment Court No. 1 of Pamplona has ruled that between the digital labour platform Glovo and its delivery riders there is an employment relationship, and that the drivers are not self-employed workers, as stated by the company.

The riders argued that Glovo exercises control over their work through a rating system, which affects their ability to select hours and earn a living. Additionally, the riders claimed that Glovo's system of assigning tasks and monitoring performance in real-time is an example of controlling, where algorithms ensure objectives are met and activities comply with standards.

The lawsuit was filed by 206 Glovo delivery workers and the trade union confederation CCOO.

Motivation for ruling in favour of employee status:**

  • Control and supervision: Glovo exercises real-time control through its platform.

  • Limited autonomy: Riders' freedom is mostly theoretical, with real restrictions in practice.

  • Employer sanctions: Ability to penalise riders for performance issues.

  • Dependency and organisation: Work is organised and controlled by Glovo, not independent.

  • Non-exclusivity not proven: No significant evidence of riders working for other companies in a similar capacity.


Additional metadata

Keywords
platform characteristics and business model, employment status
Actors
Platform, Individual worker, Government, Court
Sector
Transportation and storage

Sources

Citation

Eurofound (2022), Pamplona employment Court rules in favour of employment status for 206 Glovo riders (Court ruling), Record number 4404, Platform Economy Database, Dublin, https://apps.eurofound.europa.eu/platformeconomydb/pamplona-employment-court-rules-in-favour-of-employment-status-for-206-glovo-riders-110153.